Mmm...A Warm and Fuzzy Abortion Post
So, Dadahead has this post up on abortion where he basically laments the lack of serious discussion on the issue amongst left-leaning blogs. It's a fair point so I thought I would take up the challenge. Here are my very sensitive, very nuanced views on abortion:
If you are not a female talking about the amorphous little blob inside of your own womb, then shut the fuck up. Close your arrogant little spout-pipe and stop telling women what to do with their reproductive organs. I guess I have trouble dealing with this issue in a measured way since there is absolutely nothing to it. The consequences of this issue are serious...Alito was a one-issue selection for the Supreme Court and at some point over the next year abortion rights will undoubtedly be abolished. So the issue is serious, but the anti-abortion arguments fueling it are not. They're a joke, and for several reasons.
First of all: acorns aren't oak trees, cheese is not milk and pseudo-fetal blobs aren't people. Before we are people, we are an inconsequential dollop of oozing sexual residue. We're the result of two mammals fucking and I have a real hard time attaching any mystical significance to that. Here's a little dramatization that may help demonstrate my point:
Some random guy: Uhnnn! Uhnnn!
Some woman: Yes! Uhnnn! Yes!
Some guy: *squirt*
The end
Wow, the beginning of life really is a holy and beautiful mystery, isn't it?
Secondly, and most importantly, there is no such thing as a soul. Period. What kind of backwards, hill-billy jackass still believes in a soul? And if you do, stop believing in it. Grow the fuck up. Or better yet, if you still believe in magical, invisible spirits, abort yourself. You are too impressionable and too easily confused to make it in this world. I am absolutely sick of your mindless little fairly tales being confused for political debate you pre-programmed, superstitious little retardo-bot. Just shut up and abort yourself, please.
Ahem. I tend to fixate on the soul issue because that is the entire basis of the anti-abortion argument. Everything else is sleight of hand. People (supposedly) oppose abortion because a pristine, innocent soul is being snuffed out. This is an absurd argument and, obviously, it's a religious argument, there is no place for it in law or government.
Do you have a right to believe in the soul? Of course. Although I'm embarrassed by the existence of religion, I think it's free practice is a beautiful thing. (Seriously, about the only perk with atheism is that I get to sleep in on Sunday mornings; its not like my die-and-rot belief system has much to offer). Do you have a right to believe in the soul without me making fun of you? No. No you don't. If that's a problem...if you are one of these Christians who loves to play the victim role and make noise about how terribly persecuted you feel, here's what you can do: you can toughen up. You can finally, for the first time in your life, stop acting like a thin skinned little bitch. Think about it: you worship a messiah who was nailed to a cross! As a Christian the least you can do is put up with few unpleasant words every now and then. Were I to say, "My dad is tough. He can beat up your dad". And you say,"No he can't", and I start crying and blubbering about how persecuted I feel, I'm going to look like a real pussy aren't I? Don't be that Christian. It sends a bad message.
In summary: A woman's body is her body, fuck-blobs aren't people and the soul is a myth. You can personally accept the anti-abortion position, but no genuinely democratic society should ever make it a law.
I don't know, this really wasn't as satisfying as I had hoped. I was looking for a bit of catharsis here. I guess it's frustrating because the people who need to understand the irrelevance of their superstitions won't due to the fact that I am not a terribly effective communicator. I would very much like to get through to one of these people, but I inevitably find myself preaching to the choir (and/or singing to the preacher) and I hate that. My views aren't very...marketable, shall we say. Maybe I just need to be more accepting of people and do a better job of compromising. Hmm...here is my offer to the pro-lifers out there: if you will agree with me on this issue, I will pretend that The Passion of the Christ isn't a boring, piece of shit film. Deal? Seriously, I feel like we are bonding already.
If you are not a female talking about the amorphous little blob inside of your own womb, then shut the fuck up. Close your arrogant little spout-pipe and stop telling women what to do with their reproductive organs. I guess I have trouble dealing with this issue in a measured way since there is absolutely nothing to it. The consequences of this issue are serious...Alito was a one-issue selection for the Supreme Court and at some point over the next year abortion rights will undoubtedly be abolished. So the issue is serious, but the anti-abortion arguments fueling it are not. They're a joke, and for several reasons.
First of all: acorns aren't oak trees, cheese is not milk and pseudo-fetal blobs aren't people. Before we are people, we are an inconsequential dollop of oozing sexual residue. We're the result of two mammals fucking and I have a real hard time attaching any mystical significance to that. Here's a little dramatization that may help demonstrate my point:
Some random guy: Uhnnn! Uhnnn!
Some woman: Yes! Uhnnn! Yes!
Some guy: *squirt*
The end
Wow, the beginning of life really is a holy and beautiful mystery, isn't it?
Secondly, and most importantly, there is no such thing as a soul. Period. What kind of backwards, hill-billy jackass still believes in a soul? And if you do, stop believing in it. Grow the fuck up. Or better yet, if you still believe in magical, invisible spirits, abort yourself. You are too impressionable and too easily confused to make it in this world. I am absolutely sick of your mindless little fairly tales being confused for political debate you pre-programmed, superstitious little retardo-bot. Just shut up and abort yourself, please.
Ahem. I tend to fixate on the soul issue because that is the entire basis of the anti-abortion argument. Everything else is sleight of hand. People (supposedly) oppose abortion because a pristine, innocent soul is being snuffed out. This is an absurd argument and, obviously, it's a religious argument, there is no place for it in law or government.
Do you have a right to believe in the soul? Of course. Although I'm embarrassed by the existence of religion, I think it's free practice is a beautiful thing. (Seriously, about the only perk with atheism is that I get to sleep in on Sunday mornings; its not like my die-and-rot belief system has much to offer). Do you have a right to believe in the soul without me making fun of you? No. No you don't. If that's a problem...if you are one of these Christians who loves to play the victim role and make noise about how terribly persecuted you feel, here's what you can do: you can toughen up. You can finally, for the first time in your life, stop acting like a thin skinned little bitch. Think about it: you worship a messiah who was nailed to a cross! As a Christian the least you can do is put up with few unpleasant words every now and then. Were I to say, "My dad is tough. He can beat up your dad". And you say,"No he can't", and I start crying and blubbering about how persecuted I feel, I'm going to look like a real pussy aren't I? Don't be that Christian. It sends a bad message.
In summary: A woman's body is her body, fuck-blobs aren't people and the soul is a myth. You can personally accept the anti-abortion position, but no genuinely democratic society should ever make it a law.
I don't know, this really wasn't as satisfying as I had hoped. I was looking for a bit of catharsis here. I guess it's frustrating because the people who need to understand the irrelevance of their superstitions won't due to the fact that I am not a terribly effective communicator. I would very much like to get through to one of these people, but I inevitably find myself preaching to the choir (and/or singing to the preacher) and I hate that. My views aren't very...marketable, shall we say. Maybe I just need to be more accepting of people and do a better job of compromising. Hmm...here is my offer to the pro-lifers out there: if you will agree with me on this issue, I will pretend that The Passion of the Christ isn't a boring, piece of shit film. Deal? Seriously, I feel like we are bonding already.

14 Comments:
At 11:00 AM,
Mel said…
Here's an interesting thought I heard on NPR recently - the abortion "debate" isn't so much about debating the overall rightness/wrongness of a medical procedure as it is fueling political fires in order to give the voters the feeling their representative governments actually care about "the issues". If the decision about abortion rights is handed back to the state legislatures, which is what would happen if Roe v. Wade was overturned, then it would galvinize liberal leaning folks into more political activity in order to swing things back their way. The law scholar I heard talking about it from this point of view called Roe v. Wade the "gift that keeps on giving".
At 2:45 PM,
Christopher said…
Many, if not most, of those opposed to abortion are conservative white men who, while all for the various wars the US is prone to get into, with all their concomitant loss of life, nonetheless bemoan the loss of a precious human life when an abortion is performed.
If these white men were honest with themselves, and lived the examined life, they would see that their opposition to abortion has more to do with their hostility to women - wishing to keep them dependent on men through being barefoot and pregnant – than with anything else.
This is as good an illustration as any that there are always two reasons why we do anything: the stated reason, and the real reason.
I have a feeling I've left a similar comment on one of your blogs long ago. But the truth is worth saying over and over and over and over and ov.......zzzzzzzz
At 11:27 PM,
Unknown said…
Understood. And agreed.
Please explain, "cheese is not milk." Or may be you don't need to. What's an occasional mixed metaphor between friends?
At 2:27 AM,
Sheryl said…
I admit that I am the choir, but I really enjoyed this post, Matt. Very well written. :-)
At 7:49 AM,
Impulsivecompulsive said…
I guess it's frustrating because the people who need to understand the irrelevance of their superstitions won't due to the fact that I am not a terribly effective communicator.
Nope. I'd say you communicated that message quite effectively. Bluntly, really. Blunt is good.
Yeah, you probably didn't win any allies from the anti-abortion crowd, but you definately got your point across.
Very nice.
At 12:52 PM,
Samwick said…
Lavender: "The law scholar I heard...called Roe v. Wade the "gift that keeps on giving".
Oh I hope this is the case, we need to have some sort of practical backlash at some point. There has been discontent for years, but no realy political impact, so hopefully this will indeed cause a counterbalance of some sort.
Christopher: "But the truth is worth saying over and over and over and over and ov.......zzzzzzzz"
I hope you have narcolepsy because those are really good points, very much right on . Well, I don't HOPE you have narcolepsy, that wouldn't be fun, but I hope you're not snoozing at your own wordery, since that is what's fueling all of this. There is no doubt that this is all just a power struggle, this pretense about the "soul" is bullshit.
Hi Joe. Actually, I didn't realize they were still one vote shy, for some reason I had been thinking the game was over, so that's is really good to know. I sort of get frustrated and lapse into worst case scenarios a little too quickly sometimes.
Lady Paul: Please explain, "cheese is not milk."
Hmm. I think that cheese, before it is cheese, is milk, so I was trying to point out this progression which still retains it's key distinctions, in the same way that acorns become oak trees yet are not, in fact, oak trees. Is this making sense? Er. It's not, is it? And I'm not even sure that cheese does come from milk. I guessed. Any time I guess bad things tend to happen. So yes, mixed metaphors are more than acceptable between friends...I just hope you don't mind having a friend who is very confused every once and awhile (that is, often). Hi.
Sheryl: glad you are a part of the choir. I tend to just spout out my rantish cursing and never know who is going to loathe it. I mean, I'd be happy if a evangelical type read through and felt offended, but I'm always worried about pushing away the favorites, you know?
Impulsive: you're the only person who curses more than I do, it's awesome, so if you approve of this than I am quite happy. Usually when I type up a rant I think, not "what would Jesus do", but "what would Impulsive do?" You're becoming the muse for disgruntled rantaholics.
At 11:22 AM,
Impulsivecompulsive said…
Well shucks Matt. Thanks!
At 11:43 AM,
Unknown said…
You and I were thinking from different directions.
You: acorn FROM oak, cheese FROM milk.
I: acorn TO oak, milk TO cheese. (blastocyte TO fetus TO baby)
Glad I could clear this one up.
PS: I must remind you of your nitpicky English teacher in grade school - first spelling, now metaphor. What a bore! Watch out for a post coming soon on my blog. I humbly bow to you there.
At 12:38 PM,
Unknown said…
The post is up. Check it out.
At 10:56 PM,
Sheryl said…
Matt,
I like it when people cut through the crap and just say it like it is. And that is what you did here really well.
Also raw language like this has the advantage of being both funny, but also direct and honest. :-)
At 9:45 AM,
Anonymous said…
Hi Matt. Another very funny and hard-hitting post. I agree with you on abortion, you know I don't agree at all on questions of soul/spirit but I also know the context in which you make those specific comments... and in that context, I can see why. You're such a loveable bitch when all's said and done. >;-)
Haven't felt your presence chez Spicy for a long, long time. You might be interested to know I got into a bit of an angry one myself this week, having discovered a rant against gay people adopting which, against my better judgement - which is to leave prats alone - I fired a commentary missile at. Not often I get angry like that but man, it felt good. So how are YOU doing? Let me know, my friend! Drop by for a virtual cuppa! x
At 2:14 PM,
Mindwyrm said…
slight subject change but still related. Since abortion is usually defended as a reproductive right for a woman does a man have any reproductive rights at all?
At 10:04 PM,
Sheryl said…
They have the right to remain silent. Anything they say or do... ;-)
At 10:07 PM,
Sheryl said…
All kidding aside, isn't it great how some of the most passionate feminists are guys.
I was talking to a guy a while back who said he figured that not wanting children would be a great trait to breed for.
Post a Comment
<< Home